Solar Problems

Discussion in 'Off Grid Living' started by wpmasterdesign, Apr 2, 2017.


  1. arleigh

    arleigh Goophy monkey

    This may be too late in the game for you, but I have switch on every single panel and battery mill and generator in my system , that way I can isolate problems and panels or batteries that are not performing .
    My very first system I set up this switching along with a chalk board ,because at the time I was using used marine batteries and most of my panels than were all second hand as well .
    Any battery that couldn't maintain voltage off line was turned in and eventually another became available.
    It's great to have line meters both high and low amps and voltage to switch through so you know just how things are performing.
    Eventually you learn that though all your panels are the same model number they are not all the same , but so long as they produce enough to show a charge in the system they are a contributor . the fact holds true with batteries as well. anomalies exist in every thing.
    I have many different size panels feeding my bank. a battery or panel that fails, which is tied into the system is going to be drawing down the system unless you have a way of 1. knowing and 2. isolating it, till you can get to it.
    I have gotten panels that had been removed from systems that failed and all it was , were the diodes . some however do fail because the connection in the panel it's self were sub standard from the factory .Nothing can be done for these panels short of cutting up and hacking to find a working portion that might be usable.

    I have batteries that are all 6 volt deep cycle golf cart type , this gives me the option of making any combination I need for stepped up voltages. I also use 6 volts for LED lights through out the house. 12 volts for other lights and fans .
    The bottom line is all things age and the numbers are not carved in stone .
    If you have no way of tracking the individuals in your your system, the guess work of numbers ( what they are suppose to be ) will sour you interest .
    Build with better wire than required. solid connections and switching , diodes that match the panel, and meters that are reliable so that as things age you have the best information available concerning your system.
     
    sourdough145 likes this.
  2. I definitely see your point. And that is another advantage to these small modular setups I think. Each consists of just 1-2 battereis, 1-2 panels and of course 1 cc and inverter. So finding bad parts is much easier. Also, since the batteries are not interconnected to each other, but rather swapped back and fourth, I don't need to go through an entire bank to find a bad battery.
     
  3. techsar

    techsar Monkey+++

    Wpmd, I would suggest going larger with your panels, perhaps in the 130 - 150 watt range. My reasoning is as follows...on cloudy or partially occluded days, you'll want the extra to top off the batteries. Also, many batteries don't do too well if all they ever see is a trickle charge. My very first experiment used a 45 watt panel and a 100 ah battery. It would keep the battery charged, but didn't provide enough power to recharge it after moderate use.
    Next, I recommend going with a higher quality charge controller. MPPT would be best, but you would likely not see enough improvement to justify the added expense...until you start expanding your system and realize you are buying items that you wish you would have spent the money on the first time!
    Looking at the electronics you wish to operate, a pure sine wave inverter would be better suited. Xantrex has some small-ish ones (1800w) that do ok.
    Keep in mind that going the cheapest route usually isn't. When one part fails, it can cascade. Charge controller fails, ruins the battery. Inverter fails, ruins what was plugged in...and so on. Buy the best you can afford...it will help you in the long run :)
     
    sourdough145 likes this.
  4. Hey, thanks, Techstar! I actually relate to your first point from previous experience.
    I actually do have some alternative picked out:

    CC: Amazon.com : MPPT TRACER 3215RN Solar Charge Controller 30A 12V 24V EP : Renewable Energy Charge Controllers : Patio, Lawn & Garden
    Inverter: Amazon.com: Wagan EL2601 Elite 400W Pro Pure Sine Inverter: Automotive
    Or kind of a middle ground between what I have and an mppt:
    Amazon.com : ENZPOWER 40Amp PWM 12V 24V Auto With LCD Intelligent Solar Panel Battery Regulator Solar Charge Controller Temperature Compensation (LCD-40A) : Patio, Lawn & Garden
    OR
    Amazon.com: Power TechON PS1005 Pure Sine Wave Inverter (1500W Cont/3000W Peak): Automotive
    (But I am concerned the 1500w may be a bit of overkill)
    Another option I am looking at:

    Amazon.com: AIMS Power (PWRI60012S) 600W Pure Sine Power Inverter with Cables: Electronics

    Of course these alternatives would mean I have to change my wiring, right?
    Oh, and wouldnt I also have to jump to a 24v system? This track wont work well for a 12v will it?
    What do you think of those alternatives?
     
  5. techsar

    techsar Monkey+++

    I've gone through several inverters...the only ones still in operation were not made in China. All of those foreign units lasted less than a year. The Xantrex was taken out of service after three years due to a major system upgrade. The Trace inverters now have been running along trouble-free for a couple years.

    If you are serious about a reliable solar system, stay away from the Chinese pieces. It just isn't worth the aggravation of replacing stuff on a regular basis.

    This probably isn't what you want to hear, as the prices are not even comparable...but as the saying goes, "buy once, cry once."
     
  6. sourdough145

    sourdough145 Holder of the M1 thumb award...

    I like and use Xantrex equipment and will heartily agree you get what you pay for....
    Using a small sinewave inverter for all your small electronics is a good option leaving a large one for heavy loads (Xantrex is a good inverter with low standby drain) .
    Best operating overall is at 1/3 to 1/2 rating of inverter YMMV.
    Batteries are best charged with a tristate charger.... Big charge rate for most of cycle tapering off to light charge for last 10 to 20 %, lastly a keep alive level to take up any loads applied. Charge rate for initial charge should be at least 1/10 of battery capacity IE: 100ah should be charged at 10 amp rate for initial charging in morning (up to 1/5 or 20 amps for this example). If you have 240ah of battery you should be able to generate 24 amps for charging.... Soooo 12 X 24 = 288 watts min (better yet 400watts)
    Panels are now cheaper per watt as you go up in size and in quantity... with a plus of easier wiring....
    With two batteries it's always nice to dump the extra current unused from the charging of one to run loads and maintain the other.... Max usage of available power. Remember you can only use as much power as you make (less any losses like taxes). Limited charge time (power daylight hours) only give so much power. 6 hours of daylight charge at 1/10 rate only charges around 50% when losses are included. That's plenty depending on how much power you use in a day and assuming no clouds...
     
  7. Actually Techstar, that is exactly the kind of honest advice I want to hear!
    I am not sure where they were made, but all over the web I have seen pretty damn good ratings on the Tracer MPPT CC and on the Power TechOn 1500w inverter. I have found very few bad reviews of either. So those I think are good options. The others I admit may not be and I really do thank you for your honesty.
     
  8. ghrit

    ghrit Bad company Administrator Founding Member

    This is one of those things that has to be carefully watched. Not all batteries like the same charging scheme, so read your O&M.
     
    amcvolts likes this.
  9. Cruisin Sloth

    Cruisin Sloth Special & Slow

    @wpmasterdesign
    Quit wasting Time & money
    Xantrex is a has been , Buy a KID & spend money ONCE !!!
    http://www.midnitesolar.com/pages/kid/index.php

    And get the FULL specs of the panels
    I run Canadian Solar 350W 37.6 VOC 30.6 VMP 8.22 ISC 7.87 IMP

    Thats full specs to help , If not your going to hate solar .
    This is not hard , but it's above many .

    BUY Quality first !!
    Sloth
     
    BTPost likes this.
  10. Cruisin Sloth

    Cruisin Sloth Special & Slow

    Like I poseted in # 22,29 & 33 on this thread & still no acknowledgement
    60 watts to 100 is the read.
     
  11. sourdough145

    sourdough145 Holder of the M1 thumb award...

    True... just going by his post on what batteries purchased.... FWIW lead acid type battery. Most good chargers will have a setting for the battery being used... Follow instructions and maybe it will work out...
     
  12. BTPost

    BTPost Stumpy Old Fart,Deadman Walking, Snow Monkey Moderator

    You will NOT be sorry with that choice for a CC.... Take a look at Magnum Inverters, as well as the Outback Power Systems ones.... even if you must save up for a while.... Much better to buy once, and buy RIGHT, than buy twice or three times, getting what will be a Quality Product....
     
  13. I was looking at an outback yesterday. I think it was like 250ish range. It is high on my list
     
    sourdough145 likes this.
  14. Cruisin Sloth

    Cruisin Sloth Special & Slow

    Very good choice , I have 2 kids , 3 brats & 5 classics in service .
    CDN solar is a the best made CN solar panels . .
    Outback is better than than Magnum in the term You can do field service & replace internal boards all around the WORLD !!

    Buy only once & i got some smoking deals with e-bay

    You get what you pay for ,
    The China crap has cost me 1800.00 USD of teaching !!!

    Sloth
     
  15. Meadster.1

    Meadster.1 Monkey

    I'm using a 800 watt panels into 2 x 88 voc and 72 v at 11 ah into midnight classic , output is 40~50 amps in full sun into 4x @210 amp - 6 v golf cart batteries

    Look at the150 classic it cost more but worth it

    Also home Depot had grape solar 100 w panel on sale for $99
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 24, 2017
    sourdough145 likes this.
  16. ghrit

    ghrit Bad company Administrator Founding Member

    If you are talking about the HD in Vestal, you might want to check their prices against the website. I've not been there in over a year, but they were not too competitive back then, I beat them in the local mom and pop hardware. Not on solar stuff, but on general hardware stuff.
     
  17. Cruisin Sloth

    Cruisin Sloth Special & Slow

    One Classic 150 With MNGP is only set at one voltage , Even if the panels are wonky ., the higher voltage drive the lesser towarm up more & produce less . Heat gun them & currant the Amps
     
  1. T. Riley
  2. TnAndy
  3. DKR
  4. Prepper12
  5. Prepper12
  6. Prepper12
  7. Yad Tsalach
  8. Gafarmboy
  9. Big Ron
  10. Ganado
  11. TnAndy
  12. Navyair
  13. thatclyde
  14. Sojourn
  15. Yard Dart
  16. jcsok
  17. Cruisin Sloth
  18. ED GEiN
  19. Redi2
survivalmonkey SSL seal        survivalmonkey.com warrant canary
17282WuJHksJ9798f34razfKbPATqTq9E7